descriptors = recorte, seltz, rodwailer, pildan, realiza, regulact, perfacinta, naylon, pizote, psicofarmacologia, sexismo, piocha, niclosamida, robloxs, picheta, redilas, rotwailer, sandalo, presistin, notredame, putumayo, sadasi, nipon, oclocracia, pic18f4550, seor, raviolis, premastan, rodajas, nerv, nebbiolo, riguroso, rappy, sinave, neodimio, narices, seltaferon, pais, netilmicina, sacerdocio, montesori, pordiosero, neomicol, sipse, otamatone, pemc, remates, rojas, rebanadas, obao, sendaya, rotondi, solaz, motivar, patitos, paje, rayople, sateg, portagafete, simbolab, pster, perigeo, sinequias, reconvencin, sentencias, snellen, percusin, protena, posmoderno, sanha, permanente, podadoras, novem, scappino, ninfomano, ratzinger, rimbaud, proyect, reclutalia, mx.myherbalife, normex, siniestro, pegar, nanociencia, oriente, saori, pleuresa, simetra, paradero, peperami, seybaplaya, porcelanato, scenet, sabumafu, queratoconjuntivitis, orangel, rocku, ravioles, quirelli, plastienvases, rockstars, pectorales, neoltico, monje, ovula, siwon, oportunidades, netclinic, pisapapeles, pisis, obviamente, rembolso, redotex, nenagamer, operculectomia, otorrino, simivf, neofito, moscovio, priceshoes, sialoadenitis, rentabilidad, skidion, plumn, perceptivo, nmero, petroqumica, oxgeno, psicolgico, seara, rcord, psiclogia, pergaminos, piuttec, morza, riosan, prostitucion, ornitologo, seleccionar, protn, pirilamina, proviene, procainamida, rodamiento, psicopedagogia, quinceaera, onlyfns, shingrix, pochutla, popers, nalgadas, solapa, sidolil, pochote, motherson, obtuvo, prehispanica, roseta, pelet, portones, motoneurona, permanecer, peso.colombiano, prjimo, quedarse, presbitero, ramillete, plantoscopio, muro, rehiletes, palitos, nebido, semex, solgaleo, pubbelly, platas, piezoelctrico, rayden, ramsar, simultaneidad, sacrebleu, partenogenesis, nocivo, pedagogica, semantico, smoliv, pechugon, revox, oin, sobrepeso, rancheras, secrecion, prepago, ruber, prosaica, sedicion, reliquia, mdica, organice, monsteras, samsbenefits, quitosano, salus, smg360, pokis, osopan, moluscos, perecedero, recico, representante, serviacero, receso, sisbest, mosquiteros, monousuario, ornitofobia, orozco, saqueo, polimetilmetacrilato, roncopatia, seretonina, siniiga, rumiante, parkinsonismo, peona, riopam, neuronup, nuria, paquicefalosaurio, proposito, quieres, simpatico, prototipo, perfiles, picina, negociaciones, piovi, principes, optazol, moltres, relmpago, refrijerador, pungsan, pickwin, pron, seas, pregchan, solicita, prefabricados, relajarse, obregon, neparvis, peptidoglicano, pei.guanajuato, omuro, sirope, rosarios, papus, primeros, referir, pargeverina, siavi, peneque, perifrasis, representar, semillero, piocolecisto, nortex, nies, rioneras, soianet, pambaso, primosiston, ocaso, portagarrafon, recal, porhb, sener, quisiese, plomera, prospectivo, nutriente, obrero, puttanesca, silogismos, profecional, novolexin, pulcro, slashers, psicastenia, pasala, muina, ranunculos, sitsa, raudo, quadriderm, premisas, munchlax, raquitico, rabadilla, rentalika, preveer, popoyote, qo312l125g, podredumbre, pelele, pixrl, poemhub, portaminas, nimuari69, sansflu, pramo, pecaminoso, notropil, sedesu, okiku, pertinentes, nutrigel, pelisgratis, quimiosntesis, sisat, prncipe, narcopresidente, roncha, puntillismo, piqu, putativa, sambueza, radioterapia, parodiando, policiaca, morfo, profe, nisiquiera, polivalencia, peralvillo, pregnancia, sistematizar, sanja, nabo, monomero, popelina, pantunfla, poliester, multytecho, monterry, multiplicar, pezzil, orlistad, nortea, porjam, monigote, scolopendra, sanjudas, rodillo, prolec, preservativos, prohibicion, refractarios, profesores, resumir, repetidores, plantival, padrino, sexovideos, solowrestling, schettino, sofom, sectas, occc, pesca, parathormona, patlabor, pennylove, relevos, ramsa, padecimiento, pornogey, patona, pendeja, piquet, pipeso, semitendinoso, ojeras, netsicom, presley, sincitial, naranjito, mostradores, rossel, polivigomis, paramont, prospectos, secorse, polarizacion, nubain, periodontograma, pnico, pildoras, sagrado, rorro, nuvoil, mostrar, publicitarios, schoenstatt, perverstage, psicotropicos, sabiduria, riilax, parhikuni, panduit, musicograma, santnader, notarias, nocnok, rmn, putero, navolato, secso, porteria, neuroglias, populismo, siembra, portapapeles, recoleccion, sodoma, mucormicosis, personalismo, probabilidades, recidiva, reing, principalmente, plenafem, realizacin, naftaleno, oseo, osteitis, motomoto, secundarias, naci, pedimentos, sisma, picoro, perjuicios, precos, nomofobia, saturacin, sinefrina, nevrika, nervio, mnaco, navo, otani, recipientes, partenon, sismologia, punible, obeso, nopalera, osterizer, poligono, sancin, simib, qumica, rotavapor, pantimedias, noraxidexina, morsa, silijet, sanalona, nerdtv, rappid, ponis, resumer, rasterbator, nopalia, semntica

The VR Casino Revolution: How Virtual Reality, Free Spins, and Payment Security Are Redefining Online Gaming in 2026

The year 2026 feels like the moment the casino floor finally left the brick‑and‑mortar world and stepped into a fully immersive digital lounge. Thanks to ubiquitous 5G, headset prices that sit comfortably under $300, and a wave of blockchain‑backed payment solutions, operators are no longer confined to flat‑screen slots and static tables. Players now log in, slip on a headset, and find themselves inside a three‑dimensional casino that reacts to every head turn, hand gesture, and heartbeat.

At the same time, the classic lure of free‑spin promotions remains as potent as ever. What used to be a simple “20 free spins on Starburst” has mutated into interactive bonus rooms where a spin of a virtual wheel can unlock a cascade of extra rounds, each rendered in real time with haptic feedback. The promise of risk‑free play still drives acquisition, but the delivery method has become a theatrical experience that blurs the line between gaming and social gathering.

Security, however, has not been left to chance. Regulators across Europe, North America, and the Middle East have tightened standards for biometric authentication, tokenised wallets, and real‑time fraud monitoring. Payment‑security frameworks now sit at the core of every VR casino architecture, ensuring that the excitement of a virtual jackpot does not expose a player’s financial data.

This article unpacks how immersive VR lounges, sophisticated free‑spin mechanics, and hardened payment protocols intersect to reshape the online gambling landscape. We will trace the technology’s evolution, examine the regulatory backdrop, and offer practical guidance for operators eager to claim a slice of the rapidly expanding market.

From Slots to Immersive Lounges – The Evolution of the Online Casino Experience

The first wave of online gambling in the early 2000s relied on simple HTML frames and static graphics. By 2015, HTML5 allowed responsive design, and mobile play surged, but the visual experience remained two‑dimensional. The turning point arrived with the rollout of 5G networks and the mass adoption of lightweight VR headsets in 2022. These advances reduced latency to under 20 ms, a threshold that makes motion‑to‑action feel instantaneous—crucial for fair play and player comfort.

Key milestones accelerated adoption. In 2023, the first blockchain‑enabled casino launched a token‑based wallet that could be accessed from within a virtual environment, proving that crypto and VR could coexist. The following year, major operators integrated motion‑capture SDKs, allowing avatars to mimic real‑world gestures such as tossing dice or pulling a lever. By 2025, regulatory bodies in Malta and the UK issued guidelines for VR‑specific responsible‑gaming tools, giving the industry a clear compliance pathway.

Free‑spin mechanics have not been left behind. Traditional spin‑the‑reel offers have been re‑imagined as kinetic experiences: a player steps onto a rotating platform, pulls a virtual lever, and watches the reels spin around them in a 360‑degree arena. Bonus rooms now feature “spin wheels” that trigger mini‑games, while treasure‑hunt quests reward players with clusters of free spins hidden throughout a virtual casino hall. These adaptations keep the core appeal—extra chances to win without wagering—while leveraging the immersive potential of VR.

Key evolution points

  • 2000‑2010: Browser‑based slots, limited graphics.
  • 2015‑2021: Mobile‑first design, HTML5, live dealer streams.
  • 2022‑2024: 5G rollout, headset affordability, first VR lounges.
  • 2025‑2026: Blockchain wallets, motion‑capture SDKs, regulator‑approved VR tools.

The result is a seamless blend of classic casino economics with a sensory‑rich environment that encourages longer sessions and higher engagement.

The Technical Backbone – VR Infrastructure and Real‑Time Rendering

Delivering a flawless VR casino experience hinges on two technical pillars: rendering performance and secure data pipelines. Cloud‑based rendering services, such as NVIDIA CloudXR, offload heavy graphics processing to remote servers, streaming the final frame to the headset at 90 fps. This model reduces the hardware burden on the player but introduces strict latency requirements; any delay beyond 30 ms can cause motion sickness and raise fairness concerns.

Edge computing mitigates this risk by positioning micro‑data centers within 10‑20 km of major population hubs. Operators now route motion data to the nearest edge node, where the scene is rendered, encrypted, and sent back to the headset in under 20 ms. The tight loop not only preserves immersion but also secures transaction data, as each packet is signed with TLS 1.3 and includes a one‑time nonce generated by the player’s biometric token.

Security layers are baked directly into VR SDKs. Motion data—head orientation, hand position, and eye tracking—is encrypted with AES‑256 before transmission, preventing packet‑sniffing attacks that could reveal player behavior patterns. Anti‑cheat AI monitors avatar actions in real time, flagging abnormal spin speeds or impossible hand movements that might indicate macro usage.

Infrastructure snapshot

Component Typical Specification (2026) Security Feature
Cloud Renderer NVIDIA RTX A6000, 8 GPU cluster End‑to‑end TLS, per‑frame signing
Edge Node Intel Xeon Gold, 2 TB NVMe Zero‑trust networking, AI‑driven anomaly detection
VR SDK Unity XR 3.2 + custom anti‑cheat module AES‑256 motion encryption, biometric MFA
Latency Goal ≤ 20 ms round‑trip Real‑time fraud monitoring

By aligning rendering pipelines with robust encryption and AI oversight, operators can guarantee both visual fidelity and transactional integrity, essential for maintaining player trust in a high‑stakes environment.

Payment Security in the VR Era – New Threat Vectors and Countermeasures

As VR casinos integrate crypto wallets, biometric payments, and instant‑settlement systems, fraudsters have adapted their tactics. One emerging scheme involves “avatar hijacking,” where malicious code intercepts a player’s biometric token and re‑routes a deposit to a fraudulent address. Another vector exploits the latency gap between edge nodes and central servers, inserting a man‑in‑the‑middle (MITM) attack that swaps a fiat‑to‑crypto conversion rate mid‑transaction.

To counter these threats, operators are deploying tokenisation combined with zero‑knowledge proofs (ZKPs). Tokenisation replaces sensitive card or wallet data with a randomised identifier that is useless outside the transaction context. ZKPs enable verification of a user’s balance or age without revealing the underlying data, satisfying both AML requirements and privacy concerns. Multi‑factor authentication now extends beyond SMS codes; it incorporates biometric liveness checks (iris scan, voice pattern) and hardware‑bound one‑time passwords stored in the headset’s secure enclave.

The eGaming Security Alliance (eGSA) released its 2025 update, mandating that all VR operators implement a “Secure Transaction Layer” (STL). STL requires:

  1. End‑to‑end encryption of all payment‑related packets.
  2. Real‑time risk scoring powered by machine‑learning models trained on cross‑operator fraud datasets.
  3. Mandatory audit trails that log every wallet interaction with immutable timestamps.

Compliance with STL has become a market differentiator. Operators that publicly display their STL certification see a 12 % increase in player retention, according to a 2026 internal study by a leading Israeli payment processor.

Countermeasure checklist

  • Tokenise card and crypto wallet data before storage.
  • Deploy ZKP‑based age and AML verification.
  • Enforce biometric MFA with liveness detection.
  • Integrate STL‑compliant risk engines.

These layers create a defense‑in‑depth architecture that protects both the player’s funds and the operator’s reputation in an increasingly sophisticated threat landscape.

Free Spins Go 3‑D – How Bonus Offers Are Designed for Virtual Worlds

Free‑spin promotions have graduated from static pop‑ups to fully interactive experiences. Modern VR casinos host “spin‑the‑wheel arenas” where a player steps onto a glowing platform, pulls a virtual lever, and watches a 3‑D wheel spin in slow motion. Each segment of the wheel corresponds to a different free‑spin bundle—ranging from 5 low‑volatility spins on a classic fruit slot to 30 high‑RTP spins on a progressive adventure game.

Treasure‑hunt quests add narrative depth. Players receive a holographic map that leads them through a virtual casino’s hidden corridors. At each waypoint, a mini‑puzzle unlocks a cluster of free spins, often accompanied by multipliers or expanding wilds. Data‑driven personalization tailors these quests: AI analyses a player’s past game preferences, bet sizes, and session length to generate a bespoke free‑spin package that maximises conversion while respecting responsible‑gaming limits.

Players searching for top‑rated platforms often visit online casinos israel to discover which VR sites pair generous free‑spin promotions with robust payment safeguards. The site aggregates operator licensing information, payment‑method options, and user‑generated reviews, saving gamblers a step when they evaluate where to invest their time and money.

Typical free‑spin formats in VR

  • Spin‑the‑Wheel Arena: Real‑time physics, visual fireworks, instant credit.
  • Treasure‑Hunt Quest: Narrative‑driven, location‑based rewards, progressive unlocks.
  • Bonus‑Room Roulette: Players choose a table, spin a virtual roulette wheel, and receive a random free‑spin count.

These formats not only amplify excitement but also provide operators with granular data on player interaction, enabling further refinement of promotional strategies.

Regulatory Landscape – Licensing, Consumer Protection, and VR‑Specific Rules

In 2026, regulators have moved from reactive oversight to proactive governance of VR gambling. The Malta Gaming Authority (MGA) and the UK Gambling Commission (UKGC) now require a “Virtual Environment Audit” (VEA) as part of the licensing process. VEA assesses avatar age verification, virtual‑currency AML controls, and the adequacy of motion‑data encryption.

Key licensing requirements across major jurisdictions include:

  • Age Verification via Avatar ID: Players must upload a government‑issued ID that is cross‑checked with facial‑recognition software before an avatar can enter a VR lounge.
  • Virtual‑Currency AML: All in‑game tokens, even those used purely for cosmetic items, are subject to transaction monitoring and reporting thresholds of €10,000.
  • Session‑Time Limits: Operators must enforce a maximum of 4 hours of continuous VR play, with automatic “cool‑down” periods to mitigate addiction risks.

Compliance budgets have swelled. A mid‑size operator in Israel reports a 35 % increase in annual compliance spend, largely due to the need for biometric verification hardware, third‑party audit services, and continuous security patching of VR SDKs. Nevertheless, the regulatory clarity has encouraged investment; the number of licensed VR casinos in the EU grew by 48 % between 2024 and 2026.

Regulatory snapshot

Jurisdiction Core VR Requirement AML Threshold Notable Penalty
Malta (MGA) VEA + biometric ID €10,000 €250,000 fine or license revocation
UK (UKGC) Session‑time caps, VEA £8,000 5 % of gross gaming revenue
Israel (IGC) Crypto‑wallet tokenisation, avatar age check ₪50,000 License suspension up to 6 months
US (Nevada) No specific VR rule yet; follows traditional e‑gaming standards $5,000 Monetary fines, cease‑and‑desist

Operators that embed these rules into their development pipelines avoid costly retrofits and position themselves as trustworthy choices for risk‑aware players.

Market Leaders and Emerging Contenders – Who’s Shaping the VR Casino Space?

Established Operators

  1. SpinSphere Gaming – Launched “Sphere Lounge” in early 2025, featuring a 360° roulette table and a holographic dealer. Their security stack combines hardware‑based TPM modules with a proprietary AI fraud detector that analyses motion patterns.
  2. RoyalVR Studios – Operates “Royal Hall,” a luxury VR casino that integrates a crypto‑wallet powered by the ERC‑4337 standard. Free‑spin quests are tied to a loyalty NFT that upgrades as players complete challenges.
  3. BetWave Interactive – Offers “Wave Bay,” a seaside‑themed VR resort where players can walk from slot islands to a live‑dealer poker deck. Their payment gateway uses zero‑knowledge proof verification for all fiat deposits, eliminating the need to store card data.

Emerging Startups

  1. FreeSpin AI – Utilises a generative‑AI engine to craft bespoke free‑spin bundles in real time, adjusting volatility based on the player’s recent win‑loss streak. Their lightweight SDK runs on Android‑based headsets, lowering the entry barrier for smaller operators.
  2. HoloBet Labs – Focuses on AI‑driven free‑spin engines that embed micro‑narratives into each spin, turning a simple bonus into a short story experience. Their platform is built on a modular blockchain layer that supports instant crypto payouts.

Security Framework Comparison

Operator Encryption Standard Biometric MFA Anti‑Cheat AI Tokenisation
SpinSphere Gaming AES‑256 + TLS 1.3 Facial + voice Real‑time motion analysis Yes
RoyalVR Studios ChaCha20‑Poly1305 Iris scan Behavioural pattern AI Yes
BetWave Interactive AES‑256 + post‑quantum KEM Fingerprint + liveness Heuristic cheat detection Partial
FreeSpin AI AES‑256 Optional (depends on partner) AI‑generated spin fairness checks No
HoloBet Labs AES‑256 None (focus on UI) Narrative consistency AI Partial

Case Study – “NeonSpin”’s Integrated Free‑Spin & Crypto Wallet

NeonSpin blends instant free‑spin triggers with an encrypted crypto wallet that supports both Bitcoin and the newer Solana‑based “NeonCoin.” When a player completes a VR treasure‑hunt, the system automatically credits a batch of 20 free spins to the wallet, secured by a hardware‑bound private key stored in the headset’s secure enclave. Transactions are signed with a Schnorr signature, ensuring non‑repudiation while keeping latency under 15 ms. The wallet also features built‑in tokenisation, so no raw blockchain addresses ever leave the device, dramatically reducing exposure to phishing attacks.

Case Study – “AetherPlay”’s Biometric Payment Gateway

AetherPlay’s gateway replaces traditional passwords with a biometric token that combines iris scanning and heartbeat rhythm analysis. Upon login, the headset captures a 3‑second iris image and a 5‑second ECG trace, both hashed and stored on a decentralized ledger. Each payment request must be signed with this biometric hash, and the server validates it against the ledger in real time. The system supports instant fiat‑to‑crypto conversion, with all data encrypted using post‑quantum resistant algorithms. Because the biometric token never leaves the user’s device, even a compromised server cannot initiate unauthorized withdrawals, delivering a near‑impossible fraud barrier for VR gamblers.

Player Behavior Insights – What Gamers Want from VR Casinos in 2026

A 2026 survey of 12,000 active online gamblers across Europe, North America, and Israel reveals clear preferences. 78 % of respondents rank “immersive graphics” above “bonus size” when choosing a VR casino, while 64 % consider “payment security” a non‑negotiable factor. Free‑spin formats that involve interactive elements—such as spin‑the‑wheel arenas—receive a satisfaction rating of 4.6/5, compared to 3.9/5 for static pop‑up spins.

Demographically, Gen Z (born 1997‑2012) dominates VR adoption, accounting for 55 % of total VR casino minutes logged. Traditional players (45 +) still favour classic table games but are increasingly drawn to VR slots that offer lower volatility and higher RTP (average 96.4 %). A strong correlation emerges between perceived security and session length: players who rate an operator’s security as “high” spend on average 22 % more time per session than those who are “moderately” confident.

Key insights

  • Free‑spin type: Interactive quests > wheel spins > static offers.
  • Immersion level: 3‑D lounges with haptic feedback are the top driver of repeat visits.
  • Security expectation: Biometric MFA and tokenised wallets are now baseline requirements.

These trends suggest that operators who invest in both engaging free‑spin narratives and airtight security will capture the most valuable player segments.

The Future Roadmap – Anticipating 2027‑2029 Developments

Looking ahead, the VR casino ecosystem is poised for several breakthroughs. Haptic feedback tables, currently in beta with manufacturers like HaptX, will enable players to feel the vibration of a slot reel or the click of a roulette ball, deepening sensory immersion. AI‑generated bonus narratives will craft unique story arcs for each free‑spin session, turning a simple bonus into a mini‑adventure that adapts to player choices.

Cross‑platform wallet interoperability is another frontier. By 2028, standards such as the Interledger Protocol (ILP) are expected to allow seamless transfers between fiat, crypto, and in‑game tokens, eliminating the need for multiple wallets. The EU is drafting a “VR Gaming Directive” that will codify avatar‑based age verification, mandatory session‑time limits, and a unified AML reporting format for virtual currencies.

Economically, free‑spin economics will evolve alongside metaverse economies. Operators may issue “spin tokens” that can be traded on secondary markets, giving players a tangible asset value beyond the casino’s internal credits. This could lead to a new revenue stream where players sell unused free‑spin bundles to other gamers, creating a peer‑to‑peer bonus marketplace.

Projected timeline

  • 2027: Wide rollout of haptic tables; AI‑driven bonus storytelling pilots.
  • 2028: Adoption of ILP for cross‑wallet transfers; EU VR Gaming Directive passes.
  • 2029: Emergence of spin‑token marketplaces; full integration of biometric payment gateways across all major operators.

These developments will further intertwine immersive gameplay, promotional innovation, and security, solidifying VR casinos as a dominant force in the online gambling sector.

Practical Guidance for Operators – Implementing Secure, Free‑Spin‑Rich VR Casinos

Launching a VR casino that balances excitement with compliance requires a disciplined approach. Below is a step‑by‑step checklist to guide operators from concept to live launch.

  1. Select a technology stack – Choose a cloud renderer (e.g., NVIDIA CloudXR) paired with an edge‑computing partner that guarantees ≤ 20 ms latency. Integrate a VR SDK that includes built‑in anti‑cheat AI and motion‑data encryption.
  2. Design free‑spin experiences – Map out interactive formats (wheel arenas, treasure hunts). Use player data to personalise bundles, but ensure each offer complies with responsible‑gaming limits (max 30 free spins per 24 h).
  3. Implement payment security – Deploy tokenisation for all card and crypto data. Add biometric MFA (iris or facial) and integrate zero‑knowledge proof verification for AML checks. Ensure the Secure Transaction Layer (STL) is fully operational.
  4. Conduct regulatory audits – Submit a Virtual Environment Audit (VEA) to the relevant licensing authority. Verify avatar age verification, session‑time caps, and virtual‑currency AML controls.
  5. Run security penetration tests – Engage a third‑party firm to test edge nodes, SDKs, and wallet integrations for vulnerabilities.
  6. Budget allocation – Approximate costs: 35 % of capital expenditure on hardware (headsets, haptic tables), 25 % on licensing and compliance, 20 % on security tools, 20 % on marketing and free‑spin design.
  7. Marketing compliance – When promoting free‑spin offers, avoid language that implies guaranteed winnings. Include clear wagering requirements and age‑restriction notices in every VR lobby.

Bullet list of best practices for free‑spin design

  • Keep volatility moderate (RTP ≥ 96 %) to satisfy both casual and high‑roller players.
  • Use visual cues (glowing portals, animated avatars) to guide players toward bonus rooms.
  • Limit free‑spin sessions to 15 minutes to align with responsible‑gaming guidelines.

By following this roadmap, operators can launch a VR casino that delights players, satisfies regulators, and protects financial transactions—all essential ingredients for sustainable growth in the 2026 market.

Conclusion

The convergence of immersive virtual‑reality lounges, dynamic free‑spin promotions, and hardened payment‑security frameworks is reshaping online gambling in 2026. Operators that master the technical demands of low‑latency rendering, embed robust encryption and biometric safeguards, and craft interactive bonus experiences will capture the loyalty of a new generation of gamers. Meanwhile, players benefit from a safer, more engaging environment where the thrill of a spin is amplified by three‑dimensional realism and the peace of mind that their funds are protected. As the industry marches toward haptic tables, AI‑driven narratives, and cross‑platform wallets, the trio of VR immersion, free‑spin allure, and security will remain the cornerstone of success for anyone seeking to dominate the rapidly expanding virtual casino frontier.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *